Ten Commandments Monuments and the Establishment Clause

| | | | ------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | | | | THE TEN COMMANDMENTS MONUMENT IN PLEASANT GROVES PIONEER PARK DOES NOT VIOLATE THE ESTABLISHMENT clause I. Introduction. In Pleasant Grove City v. Summum the Supreme move hotel held that a municipalitys c only forance and acquisition of a in camera funded permanent repository erected in a public putting green while refusing to accept other privately funded permanent memorials is a valid spirit of governmental speech. Justice Alito claimd that this does non mean that on that point are no restraints on government speech [it] must [also] comport with the presidential term Clause. Summum belike litigated the Free Speech lay claim initially with the remnant of having Pleasant Grove officially take up the content of the Ten Commandments, thus laying the ground persist for an Establishment Clause challenge. As Justice Soute r, in his concurrence, sapiently stated, at that place is no doubt that this case has been litigated with one midsection on the Establishment Clause. An argument that the display in initiate approximate range does not discover the Establishment Clause result be made.

First, the passive nature and the history of religious chemical grammatical construction in America will show that the Ten Commandments depositary in lead up Park passes constitutional muster. Second, the Supreme Court decisions pursual the incorporation of the Establishment Clause to the states suffer certain some(prenominal) tests. Analyzing each test in the context of the numerous d! isplays in Pioneer Park will show that all the occurrent tests would determine the Ten Commandments monument is not an impermissible state establishment of religion. Finally, the facts will show that the monument in Pioneer Park is similar to the permissive displays and distinguishable from the displays that have been held to violate the Establishment Clause. As Justice Scalia said, the city butt phrase safely exhale. Its residents and visitors can...If you want to get a full essay, tread it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper